Add Your Review
Thanks for visiting Jimmy Z's Plates & Shakes. We'd love to have your feedback!
Our Latest Reviews
Hands down the best plates! I recommend them to literally everyone and tell them it is worth the drive. The staff is amazing and always super friendly! The meat sauce is the best meat sauce i have ever had!
My boyfriend and I frequent Jimmy's all the time! On of our favorite things to get with our meal is their milkshakes. Once we found out you can combine different flavors together it was an absolute game changer! We mix the chocolate peanut butter with the cookie dough ice cream and it's probably the best milkshake you will ever have! Cannot recommend their milkshakes enough. We've talked them up so much that family from out of state made a trip to Jimmy's during their stay just for the milkshake (and plates of course!)
I love Jimmy Z's! They have great hours, great prices and great food! They have wverything from awesome garbage plates to awesome milkshakes. The service at Jimmy Z's is impeccable, ive never waited longer than 5 minutes for my food which is impressive because they are right in a college town! Would recommend!
The food is always fresh and taste amazing! They have amazing service and prices for the amount of food. Every time I get a half plate I am stuff eating just half of it but I save the other half for lunch or dinner the next day!
Best garbage plate in Rochester!!!
Awesome plate! I'm from Syracuse, NY and wish we had something like this In the 'cuse . Never disappoints!
I can never finish the bigger plates so it is the absolute perfect size with all the delicious of a garbage plate! I did Mac salad (classic) and tator tots (best tots ever) with cheese burger and of course the meat sauce and onions. I could eat this literally any day and every day!
my favorite plate there is ...great service also
Tried this for the first time a couple days ago... I've already been back two times! The food is amazing, you have so many options to chose from, you get big portions and it's all for a small price! I will go back every week now!!
I am amazed of the quality of the food. The great atmosphere, the kind service, and the general fun here. I make it a point to stop by whenever I can. And even though I moved away, I come back just for this. Jimmy and Papa make me feel welcome.
Perfect size for people who dont have a big appetite. Jimmys mac salad and meat sauce are sooooooooo good!
Offers everything you could ever want. I have been a garbage plater for as long as i can remember. Originally i was basic and kept things original with the cheeseburgers, mac salad, potato and meat sauce. I tried the all American once and never want back. You get the comfort of the cheeseburger, the taste of Rochesters own red hot aka the best hot dog on the planet, and the chicken fingers is a surpise but is delicious. The 3 proteins, mac salad and the carbs from the potatoe with a generous topping of meat sauce to put the icing on the cake. We have of southern comfort meals all the time, this is my Western NY, hometown comfort meal. One a week, month or year you never can get sick of this.
This is a perfect blend of my favorite things. It's always a nice treat when we eat at Jimmy Z's. It is high quality food, made fast, for a great price! I highly recommend you try the Jimbozilla!
Firecrackers are my absolute FAVORITE thing to get (aside from a cheeseburger plate of course). They're pizza logs dipped in sauce (I get country sweet sauce) and a side! I put mine on top of Mac salad and it's absolutely amazing!! I love me some jimmy Z's
Always consistently DELISH!
It was awesome! Who would think of that? Well I'm glad Z's did!! And their plates are better than Tahoe's!
Not my first time here and 100 percent will not be my last. Best plate in the roc and worth the drive even from East Rochester
The Barbie q brings Texas to your tastebuds with a touch of brockport! I get extra cheese!
The best and ONLY place to get a garbage plate. In fact everything that i have ever eaten there is absolutely delicious. I am a dispatcher and whenever i have a tech in the area, i always tell them to go to Jimmy Z's. They always say they love it and will be going back.
Full Garbage plate was amazing. I have had many garbage plates but Jimmy Z's is by far the best. The quality and the price go hand in hand. Trust the hype trust Jimmy Z's.
I requested the Chicken fingers to be flavored country sweet and They were so tangy. Topped with Mac salad, fries and cheddar cheese, Add some blue cheese and it was amazing. This is my go to meal. Large is enough for me to make two meals out of it.
The best fish fry that I have ever had. I can't believe that I ate the whole thing.
Had it for the first time last time i went it, instantly became one of my favorites
So amazing. I've had a lot of poutine at a lot of different places and this is by far my go-to. It's never soggy like most places and it has the perfect amount of all of the toppings. An order you won't regret!
Full garbage plate a month ago for first time, and I'm getting another one tonight. Best plates in the 585 no doubt, me and Jimmy also had a great convo when I went there about business, great guy. -Aaron
Will drive from Albion to Brockport, just for this plate. Call before we leave & it's ready/fresh by the time we get there! Portions are perfect & definitely more than 1 meal for me. Combinations are versatile, but the ol standby of 2 cheeseburger, tots & double mac salad (yes, it's that good!) topped with everything (ketchup, mustard, onion, meathot) can't be beat.
Excellent mix-up on the classic garbage plate, especially for those who like barbecue food
The Chicken Barbie Q is a great combination of bbq crispy chicken fingers piled on top of mac salad and French fries. I get mine with tator tots. It's delicious everytime!
Never have been disappointed. Wings are always cooked exactly the way we ask😊😊
Melt in your mouth! Terrific taste and portion. Nice crunch to the batter and plump, flaky delishiousness in the filet. Yum!
I have eaten here many times over the last decade and the food never disappoints! Not to mention their super tasty milkshakes for a dessert
Jimmy Z's staff is always super polite and welcoming every time we come. Day or night we're always greeted with a smile. Best garbage plate in town, the meat sauce is by far the best tasting not too spicy either. Burgers are always freshly made and the cheese is nice and melty. The wings were crispy, and sauced extremely well. Definitely 10/10 recommend to try this next time you go!
So good. Got a half size portion. Was surprised how much food was included. Definitely worth buying. Will definitely get again. It's a plate with a ton of my fave foods covered in gravy and cheese
This is my absolute favorite dessert!! When I first got it, it just looked like ice cream but when I started eating it I was surprised to find a cone full of sprinkles in the middle!! I LOOOVE sprinkles!! Now every time I go to Jimmy Z's I can't leave without getting a Pot of Jimmies. Sometimes I'll get it for my dinner... Haha!! I highly recommend this item but be warned... You WILL get addicted!!
Favorite place to go for a burger and fries! And don't forget the milkshakes... amazing flavors and they are so thick and delicious!!
Hell of a late night move! So good
This place is seriously amazing! It has the best garbage plates in the world. The fire crackers are phenomenal and the sauce just tops it off. 🔥🔥 I love coming here. Sometimes it gets a bit crazy but it's so worth the wait.
Best plate there is, period.
Buffalo BBQ hybrid plate is the best thing I've eve me eaten. Went to school up here for 4 years. Still go back just for this place. Everything changes but the Zs!!! Best place in town
PAST DRAWING WINNERS
Marsha, Stefano's Restaurant
Alma, Karai Ramen Bistro
Courtney, Axe & Arrow
Andy, Backwoods Brewing Co.
Amanda, Home Restaurant
Los Angeles, CA
Jennifer, Mark's City Grill
Rebecca, Frank Gourmet
Donna, Dino's Sports Bar
Cape Cod, MA
Karen, This Little Pig
Alicia, Plant Based Pizzeria