Raves & Reviews
Add Your Review
Thanks for visiting Jimmy Z's Plates & Shakes. We'd love to have your feedback!
Our Latest Reviews
All American Plate
Love jimmy's so much, when my father passed away and he heard the news he refused to let us pay on our next visit. I've been there so many times and All-American is the best classic I always get. Love to go in and see the same staff who know us and ask how my siblings are. Community is so important and it helps their business so much! <3
1st Timer Plate
Best food in the town of Rochester. No matter what we buy we're never disappointed we love lots of items in the menu. Great food. Amazing customer service!!!
Baconpalooza
Very filling, but I could of eaten another one
Chocolate PB
My favoritr milk shake ever!
All American Plate
My first visit here, and let me tell you this food does not disappoint!! Come hungry because the portions are huge! Delicious food, when i return to this part of town i know my first stop will definitely be Jimmy Z's!
Full Plate
Best plate around!!! Trashes other area Garbage Plates!!!!
Piece of Cake
Best Milkshake on the menu!
Mac Salad
They have the best Mac salad. And no onions!
Barbie Q
Insanely good. Everything about it, especially if you need a non-spicy alternative
Fresh J's
It's hard to pick a favorite at Jimmy's. Everything is so good! The staff is always wonderful and the atmosphere is engaging! The Fresh J's is a great go to for a little spice on a great burger, add a side of waffle fries or mac salad and your good to go!
All American Plate
Perfect every time!!! Definitely the best! I never pass up a chance to get some jimmyz 💜
Full Plate
Lived in Brockport when Jimmy opened and now live 225 miles away but make this trip frequently for a plate and a pint of meat sauce to take back with me. LOVE every single visit as Jimmy makes everyone feel like theyre at home when you walk through the door
Chicken Fingers
I had the jimmy fingers dinner with a side of Mac salad! It was all very delicious and a great portion size, I shared with my daughter and still have left overs from last night! Quick fast easy pick up for a Friday night. I am very satisfied!!!
Half Plate
I live in Jamestown now but will still make the time to go here just for this when I'm home ❤️
Bird's the Word
Such a delicious sandwich! The flavors blend together well and it tastes amazing!
Jimbozilla
This is the best thing in the entire world
The Eiffel Tower
Order every time I go here easily the best thing on the menu!
Roaster Wings
Ordered wings for pick up tonight. First time. They were ready when I arrived, cooked perfectly, and we're delicious. We have found our wing place in Brockport!
Taco Tortilla Bowl
Had It, Loved It, Will Had again and again!
French Fries
Holy smokes! I've tried so many of their foods but their salt and vinegar French fries are by far my favorite!! I've never heard of flavored fries until Jimmy Zs but man it's a brilliant idea! Strongly strongly recommend getting these with a milkshake. Perfect late night snack
All American Plate
Regular at Jimmy Z's. The plates are what you cone here for, then you try a Firecracker, or any of his burgers, and you're hooked.
Mac N' Chz Bites
Literally the best mac n cheese bites I've had in my entire life. Jimmy Zs puts a fresh spin on every delicious food item you could want. By far the best restaurant in the Rochester area in my opinion!
Fruity Pebble
This is literally the best milkshake I have ever tried. The cereal in the milkshake is still crunchy making it taste so much better ! I am addicted
Roaster Wings
Super good and amazing price. Wings were great size and crispy. Got the garlic parm and loved them
Full Plate
The best plates in this area for sure.
Roaster Wings
tasty
Fire Crackers
BBQ sauce with bleu cheese....this is why Jimmy's will always be my favorite place!
Cheeseburger
Great food, great prices and even BETTER Customer Service. This place is awesome. Great ice cream, as well as FROZEN Custard!! Wish i had found this years ago! Great place to grab some food and ice cream
Taco Tortilla Bowl
I absolutely LOVE LOVE LOVE this dish!!!
Full Plate
Ordered this yesterday! Amazing. Other then a slight mistake, I ordered a hot and a burger but received 2 burgers! Other wise wow!
Princess Plate
The "plate" is an iconic Rochester culinary tradition like no other. Somehow, Jimmy Z's improves upon an already-perfect dish. Their sauce is absolutely the best in the city, hands down; the perfect mix of spice, heat, and flavor. Plus, it comes in multiple sizes, so you can eat a small one at lunch and still be a functional human being after you're done! Five stars out of five, ten stars out of ten. Whatever your rating system, this is right on top.
Pot of Jimmies
Delicious and affordable.
Fish Fry
I abstain from meat on Fridays because of my faith. But I feel like I'm not really sacrificing much because Jimmy's Fish Fry is so heavenly! From the fish, to the fries, to the slaw it is so good, and reasonably priced. Best garbage plates from miles around as well. Kevin